The Mammoth Hunters

I’m afraid Jean M Auel is getting a bit lost in melodrama as this series goes on, and what is in many ways an interesting exploration of the roots of humanity gets caught up in a tangled and unrealistic lover’s tiff.

In this novel, Ayla who lived alone after being expelled from the Clan of the Cave Bear, and her lover Jondalar meet up with a group of mammoth hunters, known as the Mamutoi.  The Mamutoi come to appreciate Ayla’s abundant gifts – and she makes a special connection to Rydag, a half-clan boy adopted by the Mamutoi who cannot speak and suffers all the prejudice that was such as large part of the last novel.  Ayla teaches Rydag and the Mamutoi the clan the sign language , improving his quality of life tremendously.

The Mamutoi offer to adopt Ayla and give her a home, which she accepts with no people to call her own.  Jondalar supports this, although is jealous of a dark-skinned carver called Ranec who makes it clear that he wants to make Ayla his. When he invites Ayla to his bed, she accepts as per her clan conditioning.  For the rest of the novel Jondalar is jealous and removes himself from Ayla.  What is ridiculous about this is that he never speaks to her about it, and at the same times understands why she might have done it.  Then he makes excuses as to why he isn’t good enough for her, and how he still has concerns about her fitting in with his people.  It is maddening.

Ayla just doesn’t understand Jondalar, which pushes her further towards Ranec.  Its hard to believe any two characters could both be so obtuse.

There are some interesting facts to learn about life for early man, and when Ayla finds and raises a wolf cub, about man’s relationship with dogs.  But the magic of this series is wearing thin as the themes of communication breakdown from the last novel are repeated too closely in this novel as well.  Of course it all works out in the end, and we have three more novels yet to come.  I hope the themes of the next few are a little more varied.

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. Maddening is correct term with this series of books. I have read the first 5 books, and in the end can no longer be bothered with it and the sixth book that came out last year. My wife read the sixth book, but she found it repetitive, and felt Auel could have cut it in half and still have a good book. There is even Jondalar-Ayla communication issues, and plot recaps from previous books that we already know and don’t need. A bit like going over again in fine detail how Lord Voldemort killed Harry’s parents in every book of the Potter series. The first two books were good, the rest are awful.

    1. Good to hear! I am unsure if I will attack the next or not. I had been listening to these on audio, and they don’t have the next two available which means I would have to borrow them from the library. Maybe at some point – but after this last book and your comments I don’t think I will hurry!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s